Best Green Onion Grow Kit for Countertop Regrowing

Best Green Onion Grow Kit

A strong green onion grow kit holds roots at the water line, suits your jar or countertop setup, and makes regrowing scallions straightforward for home cooks. This roundup compares simple jar inserts and lids, standalone trays, a Japanese onion seed kit, and a larger sprouting set that also includes an onion sprouter. Check compatibility before choosing: some planters are made for wide-mouth jars, one is specified for regular-mouth jars, and several listings do not state a jar size.

The products also differ in how many roots they can hold and whether you receive only a planter or extra growing components. Our top choice is a two-piece kit designed for regular-mouth Mason jars, while other picks suit wide-mouth jars, seed growing, or a minimal countertop setup.

The Best Green Onion Grow Kit for most shoppers is Play as Pro Green Onion Kit. It includes two trays sized about 3.35 by 2.17 inches, designed for regular-mouth Mason jars, and holds roots above the water to help avoid over-soaking. That specific jar fit and two-piece set make it a practical choice when you already have compatible jars.

If you need wide-mouth compatibility instead, consider SIEGMANNS Onion Regrower; for a seed-based Japanese variety, choose Kyoto Kujo Negi Kit.

Our Top Picks

Play as Pro Green Onion KitBest Overall

Play as Pro Green Onion Kit

Includes two trays sized about 3.35 by 2.17 inches and is specified for regular-mouth Mason jars, with roots suspended above water.

View on Amazon
SIEGMANNS Onion RegrowerBest Wide-Mouth Fit

SIEGMANNS Onion Regrower

The reusable two-piece lid is designed for standard wide-mouth Mason jars and supports green onion and chive roots in water.

View on Amazon
Kyoto Kujo Negi KitBest Seed Kit

Kyoto Kujo Negi Kit

This kit grows heirloom Japanese Kujo Negi in a wick hydroponic Mason jar system; its planting guidance specifies 68 seeds per jar.

View on Amazon

Compare Green Onion Grow Kits by Fit and Growing Style

#ProductDimensionsWeightBuy
13.23 x 3.23 x 1.89 in2.89 ozView on Amazon
2
SIEGMANNS Onion Regrower2. SIEGMANNS Onion RegrowerBest Wide-Mouth Fit
3 x 3 x 3 in1.76 ozView on Amazon
3——View on Amazon
4
KCMOSGI Onion Planters4. KCMOSGI Onion PlantersBest Multi-Hole Insert
——View on Amazon
5——View on Amazon
6
Original Green Onion Farms6. Original Green Onion FarmsReusable two-lid jar setup
—3.2 ozView on Amazon
7
ZESTIGREENS Planter Lid7. ZESTIGREENS Planter LidSimple countertop lid option
3.5 x 3.5 x 1.63 in1.44 ozView on Amazon
8
Mini Honeycomb Regrower8. Mini Honeycomb RegrowerHoneycomb-lid counter grower
——View on Amazon
9
Bylion Sprouting Set9. Bylion Sprouting SetOnion and seed sprouting
3.3 x 3.3 x 6.5 in1.21 lbView on Amazon
10
Marinix Sprouting Kit10. Marinix Sprouting KitFull jar sprouting station
5.3 x 8.9 x 7.1 in2.8 lbView on Amazon

Detailed Reviews: Best Green Onion Grow Kit

Play as Pro Green Onion Kit

#1 · Best Overall

1. Play as Pro Green Onion Kit

  • Dimensions: 3.23 x 3.23 x 1.89 in
  • Weight: 2.89 oz

Best for: Regular-mouth root regrowing.

Why it ranks #1: Includes two trays sized about 3.35 by 2.17 inches and is specified for regular-mouth Mason jars, with roots suspended above water.

Two trays for regular-mouth Mason jars let the Play as Pro kit turn trimmed root ends into a water-based green onion growing setup. Its suspended-root design aims to keep roots at the water level without over-soaking, giving cooks a reuse-focused alternative to starting onions from seed.

The two 3D-printed trays measure about 3.35 by 2.17 inches according to the feature description, and are specified for regular-mouth Mason jars. Place trimmed roots in the trays and add water; the design suspends roots at the intended level to avoid over-soaking and rot, supporting an uncomplicated regrowing workflow. Because it uses existing root ends rather than seeds, the kit is suited to kitchen-scrap propagation. The package lists two planter kits, but does not list jars as included components.

Pros
  • Two planter trays are included.
  • Designed for regular-mouth Mason jars.
  • Uses existing root ends instead of seeds.
  • Suspended roots are intended to avoid over-soaking and rot.
Cons
  • The kit is specified for regular-mouth jars, not wide-mouth jars.

Skip it if you use wide-mouth jars; KCMOSGI’s MSGJCZZQ0623 planters are specified for wide-mouth Mason jars.

Choose this pair if your jars have regular mouths and you want to regrow trimmed onion roots in water. Its root-suspending approach suits scrap propagation, but jar-mouth compatibility is the key fit boundary.

Full product details
BrandPlay as Pro
Item Weight2.89 ounces
Item model numberASP086
ManufacturerGreen Onion Planter Kit
Dimensions3.23 x 3.23 x 1.89 inches

Listed on Amazon as: 2 Pack Green Onion Planter Kit, Sprouting Jar for Regular Mouth Mason Jar, Hydroponic Scallion Grower & Seed Sprouting System for Windowsill Garden Propagation

View on Amazon
SIEGMANNS Onion Regrower

#2 · Best Wide-Mouth Fit

2. SIEGMANNS Onion Regrower

  • Dimensions: 3 x 3 x 3 in
  • Weight: 1.76 oz

Best for: Wide-mouth scrap regrowing.

Why it ranks #2: The reusable two-piece lid is designed for standard wide-mouth Mason jars and supports green onion and chive roots in water.

Wide-mouth Mason jar compatibility anchors SIEGMANNS’ two-piece chive and green onion regrower, which uses leftover roots for repeat kitchen growing. Its lid supports the stalks while roots remain submerged in water, connecting scrap reuse with a straightforward countertop setup for fresh scallions and chives.

The reusable regrowing system is specified for standard wide-mouth Mason jars, so the jar provides the vessel while the lid holds onion or chive stalks. Keeping roots submerged supports the listed water-based growing method and makes the setup suited to kitchen-counter use. The two-piece offering can serve more than one jar or provide a spare lid, while reusing root ends addresses the stated food-waste reduction purpose. Buyers should check that their jars are standard wide-mouth size before setting up.

Pros
  • Compatible with standard wide-mouth Mason jars.
  • Works with green onion and chive root ends.
  • Lid supports stalks while roots remain submerged.
  • Two regrowers are included.
Cons
  • Requires a standard wide-mouth Mason jar, which is not listed as included.

Skip it if you use regular-mouth jars; Play as Pro’s ASP086 trays are specified for regular-mouth Mason jars.

Pick this pair if you have standard wide-mouth jars and want to regrow both chives and green onions from leftover roots. The jar-dependent format is the main fit consideration for setting up its countertop system.

Full product details
BrandSIEGMANNS
Item Weight1.76 ounces
Item model number2pk parent
ManufacturerSIEGMANNS
Dimensions3 x 3 x 3 inches

Listed on Amazon as: Chive & Green Onion Regrower for Wide Mouth Mason Jars | Scallion Regrow Kit | Mason Jar Root Growing Lid for Kitchen Scrap Regrowth | Reusable Indoor Herb Growing System (2)

View on Amazon
Kyoto Kujo Negi Kit

#3 · Best Seed Kit

3. Kyoto Kujo Negi Kit

Best for: Japanese onion seed starters.

Why it ranks #3: This kit grows heirloom Japanese Kujo Negi in a wick hydroponic Mason jar system; its planting guidance specifies 68 seeds per jar.

Kyoto Kujo Negi seeds bring a traditional Japanese bunching onion variety to this countertop kit, suited to cooks who want tender stalks with a mild flavor. Its Mason-jar wick hydroponic system supports indoor growing, while the stated planting requirement of 68 seeds per jar gives setup a specific starting point.

The kit pairs Kujo Negi onion seeds with a clean wick hydroponic system inside a classic Mason jar, giving seed growers a countertop setup rather than a roots-only regrower. The product specifies planting 68 seeds per jar, an important detail for arranging this variety in its intended vessel. The low-maintenance feature may suit indoor growing routines, and the tender, mild stalks are described for ramen, stir-fry, soups, and garnishes. It is a seed-growing option, not just a holder for leftover roots.

Pros
  • Includes Kyoto Kujo Negi Japanese onion seeds.
  • Uses a Mason-jar wick hydroponic system.
  • Specifies 68 seeds per jar for this variety.
  • Tender, mild stalks suit ramen, soups, stir-fry, and garnishes.
Cons
  • The variety’s stated setup calls for 68 seeds per jar.

Skip it if you want to regrow leftover scallion roots rather than start seeds; SIEGMANNS’ wide-mouth jar regrower uses root ends.

This kit suits cooks seeking Japanese Kujo Negi from seed in a countertop Mason-jar hydroponic setup. Follow its specific 68-seeds-per-jar requirement; choose a root-end regrower instead if you want to reuse scraps.

Full product details
BrandBraggable Gardens
ColorKyoto Kujo Negi Japanese Onion
ManufacturerBraggable Gardens
Material FeatureHeirloom
Material FeaturesHeirloom
Model NumberKyoto Kujo Negi
Special FeaturesLow Maintenance
Special FeatureLow Maintenance

Listed on Amazon as: Kyoto Kujo Negi Japanese Green Onion Indoor Garden Kit

View on Amazon
KCMOSGI Onion Planters

#4 · Best Multi-Hole Insert

4. KCMOSGI Onion Planters

Best for: Mason-jar root separators.

Why it ranks #4: Three wide-mouth jar planters each have seven holes, separating roots; jars are not included, so buyers need compatible containers.

Seven individual planting holes are the defining feature of KCMOSGI’s green onion planter, giving each root its own place instead of bunching roots together. The three plastic inserts are intended for wide-mouth Mason jars, so they offer a compact way to arrange several green onion roots for water-based kitchen growing.

Each insert measures about 3.05 by 1.57 inches and has seven 0.7-inch perforations, letting you separate roots while using a jar-based hydroponic setup. Perforated conical support feet provide stability at the jar opening, helping the planter sit in place during countertop use. The package includes three planters, useful if you want to set up multiple jars or keep spares available. The jar itself is not included, so this is an insert rather than a complete growing vessel.

Pros
  • Seven holes separate roots instead of crowding them together.
  • Three planters are included.
  • Conical support feet stabilize the insert at the jar opening.
  • Plastic inserts are intended for hydroponic growing.
Cons
  • A wide-mouth Mason jar must be supplied separately.

Skip it if you need a complete jar-and-seed kit; Braggable Gardens’ Kyoto Kujo Negi kit includes a Mason-jar hydroponic system and seeds.

Choose this set if you already own wide-mouth Mason jars and want separate planting positions for green onion roots. It is a compact insert set, not a complete kit, and the jars must be supplied separately.

Full product details
BrandKCMOSGI
ColorGreen
Item Dimensions2.76 x 2.76 x 1.57 inches
ManufacturerKCMOSGI
Part NumberMSGJCZZQ003
Model NumberMSGJCZZQ0623
Special FeaturesAeration
Size3.05*1.57 inches
Special FeatureAeration

Listed on Amazon as: 3 PCS Green Onion Planter for Wide Mouth Mason Jars, 7 Holes Green Onion Growing Container for Home Kitchen Vegetable Growing, Green Onion Regrower Kit. (Cup Not Included)

View on Amazon
YOORORO Onion Regrower

#5 · Highest Capacity

5. YOORORO Onion Regrower

Best for: Twelve-slot countertop regrowing.

Why it ranks #5: The compact water-based tray has 12 root holes and is described as breathable and portable for soil-free kitchen regrowing.

Twelve holder slots give the YOORORO tray room to organize multiple scallion roots for water-based regrowing on a kitchen counter. Its soil-free approach keeps roots hydrated without potting mix, while the compact 4.8-by-2.5-inch footprint offers a small-format option for cooks who want fresh green onions close to meal preparation.

The tray measures 4.8 inches wide, 2.5 inches deep, and 2 inches high, making its listed dimensions useful when choosing a counter spot. Place scallion roots in the 12 holder slots and use water rather than soil; the stated stable-growth and root-hydration functions support a straightforward indoor routine. Its breathable and portable features suit moving the tray around the kitchen as needed. The product is described as compatible with a green onion shredder, though the supplied details do not specify shredder dimensions.

Pros
  • Twelve slots hold scallion roots individually.
  • Water-based, soil-free setup supports cleaner indoor growing.
  • Compact listed dimensions suit a kitchen counter.
  • Breathable and portable features support moving the tray.
Cons
  • The listed dimensions are compact, limiting the tray’s footprint for larger setups.

Skip it if you need a kit with jars and several sprouting accessories; Marinix’s FYTJ01 set includes two jars, mesh lids, sleeves, a stand, tray, brush, and sprouter.

Pick this tray if you want a compact, soil-free place to regrow scallion roots near the kitchen. Its 12 slots organize a small setup, while buyers seeking jars and sprouting accessories should consider a more complete kit.

Full product details
BrandYOORORO
ColorGreen 12 Holes
Included ComponentsHolder
Item Dimensions2.5 x 4.8 x 2 inches
Dimensions2.5"D x 4.8"W x 2"H
ManufacturerYOORORO
Special FeaturesBreathable, Portable
Product StyleBohemian
Size12 Holes
Special FeatureBreathable, Portable
StyleBohemian

Listed on Amazon as: Green Onion Regrower Sprouting Kit Indoor Kitchen Herb Growing Tray Hydroponic Scallion Planter Container Vegetable Regrower System Compatible with Green Onion Shredder

View on Amazon
Original Green Onion Farms

#6

6. Original Green Onion Farms

  • Weight: 3.2 oz

Best for: Reusable two-lid jar setup.

Why it ranks #6: Two reusable green and grey hydroponic jar lids are intended to regrow leftover onions; the listing says a metal ring is optional.

Two reusable growing lids make the Original Green Onion Farms set a practical choice for turning leftover green onions into a pair of jar-based hydroponic growing stations. Its self-watering feature supports a simple countertop routine, and the green-and-grey plastic lids can be used with an optional metal ring.

Each plastic lid measures 3.5 inches across and 1.5 inches high, a compact format for jar-based growing. The two-pack lets you prepare two stations for leftover green onion regrowth, while the self-watering feature supports the product’s simple hydroponic approach. A metal ring is optional, so users can choose whether to use one in their setup. For maintenance, the supplied directions call for hand washing in cool water and air drying, rather than machine cleaning.

Pros
  • Two growing lids are included.
  • Reusable plastic construction supports repeated use.
  • Self-watering feature suits a simple hydroponic routine.
  • A metal ring is optional.
Cons
  • The lids require hand washing in cool water and air drying.

Skip it if you want a seed-starting kit with sprouting accessories; Marinix’s FYTJ01 includes mesh lids, blackout sleeves, a stand, drip tray, and brush.

This pair fits households that already have suitable jars and want reusable lids for regrowing leftover green onions. Choose it for a simple two-station setup, keeping in mind that care calls for hand washing and air drying.

Full product details
BrandGeneric
ColorGreen/Grey
Item Dimensions3.5 x 3.5 x 1.5 inches
Dimensions3.5"D x 3.5"W x 1.5"H
Item Weight3.2 ounces
ManufacturerLigerLab
MaterialPlastic
Special FeaturesEasy, Self Watering
Product StyleGarden
Special FeatureEasy, Self Watering
StyleGarden

Listed on Amazon as: 2-Pack Original Green Onion Farms

View on Amazon
ZESTIGREENS Planter Lid

#7

7. ZESTIGREENS Planter Lid

  • Dimensions: 3.5 x 3.5 x 1.63 in
  • Weight: 1.44 oz

Best for: Simple countertop lid option.

Why it ranks #7: This countertop regrower is a simple green onion planter lid, with listed dimensions of 3.5 by 3.5 by 1.63 inches.

A countertop regrower lid is the central offering from ZESTIGREENS, aimed at kitchen users who want a dedicated place for green onion regrowth. Its listed 3.5-by-3.5-inch dimensions give a useful indication of its compact format, while the product title identifies it as a planter lid rather than a full garden system.

ZESTIGREENS lists the lid at 3.5 by 3.5 inches and 1.63 inches high, dimensions that help buyers judge whether the item suits their available countertop space. The product is specifically titled a green onion planter lid and countertop regrower, so its role is focused on kitchen use rather than serving as a general sprouting kit. The supplied listing gives no further operating or material details, so this review stays with the stated lid format and measurements.

Pros
  • Specifically identified as a green onion planter lid.
  • Positioned for countertop kitchen use.
  • Listed dimensions are 3.5 by 3.5 by 1.63 inches.
  • Focused on green onion regrowing.
Cons
  • The supplied product details identify a lid but do not describe an included growing vessel.

Skip it if you want a kit with jars, a stand, and sprouting tools; Marinix’s FYTJ01 includes two wide-mouth jars and multiple accessories.

Consider this lid if you want a focused green onion regrower for kitchen-counter use and its listed dimensions suit your space. It is a narrow-format choice, rather than a documented all-in-one jar and accessory set.

Full product details
BrandZESTIGREENS
Item Weight1.44 ounces
Item model numberonion_regrower_variation
ManufacturerZESTIGREENS
Dimensions3.5 x 3.5 x 1.63 inches

Listed on Amazon as: Green Onion Planter Lid – Countertop Regrower for Kitchen Use

View on Amazon
Mini Honeycomb Regrower

#8

8. Mini Honeycomb Regrower

Best for: Honeycomb-lid counter grower.

Why it ranks #8: The mini hydroponic box has a honeycomb lid for soil-free indoor water propagation, but the listing supplies few further specifications.

A hexagonal honeycomb lid distinguishes this mini green onion regrower, combining a planter box with a soil-free water-propagation format for kitchen-counter growing. The white unit is presented as a tub for scallions and indoor herbs, giving buyers a self-contained style of setup rather than an insert described for Mason jars.

The product title identifies a mini planter box with a hexagonal honeycomb lid, a format that positions the roots in a countertop water-propagation tub. Its soil-free description means the listed growing approach uses water rather than potting soil, which may suit kitchen spaces where a contained setup is preferred. The title also names scallions and indoor herbs, broadening its stated use beyond green onions. No dimensions or maintenance instructions are supplied, so countertop placement and care details cannot be assessed further.

Pros
  • Hexagonal honeycomb lid is a distinctive root-holding feature.
  • Planter box format provides a tub-style setup.
  • Named for soil-free water propagation.
  • Listed for scallions and indoor herbs.
Cons
  • No dimensions are supplied to assess the countertop footprint.

Skip it if you need stated dimensions before choosing a counter spot; YOORORO’s 12-hole tray lists its size as 4.8 by 2.5 by 2 inches.

This mini tub suits buyers who prefer a honeycomb-lid, water-propagation format for scallions or indoor herbs. Because dimensions are not provided, it is harder to judge counter fit than with a size-listed tray.

Listed on Amazon as: Mini Green Onion Regrower Kit, Hydroponic Scallion Planter Box with Hexagonal Honeycomb Lid, Soil-Free Indoor Herb Water Propagation Tub for Kitchen Countertop, White

View on Amazon
Bylion Sprouting Set

#9

9. Bylion Sprouting Set

  • Dimensions: 3.3 x 3.3 x 6.5 in
  • Weight: 1.21 lb

Best for: Onion and seed sprouting.

Why it ranks #9: This 2-in-1 set is described for scallions and shallots and includes stainless steel mesh for sprouts, though dimensions and components are limited.

A 2-in-1 format pairs green onion regrowing with seed sprouting, making Bylion’s set an option for households that want more than one propagation task in one kit. Its bottom air holes support root growth, while the included stainless steel mesh plug is identified for sprouting broccoli sprouts.

The multifunctional kit is described for growing scallions and shallots, giving the onion side of the setup more than one named crop. Air holes in the bottom are intended to support root growth, while the stainless steel mesh plug adds a separate seed-sprouting use, specifically including broccoli sprouts. At 3.3 by 3.3 by 6.5 inches, its listed dimensions help with placement planning. The details support both regrowing and sprouting workflows, though they do not specify a cleaning routine.

Pros
  • Supports growing scallions and shallots.
  • Bottom air holes are intended to help roots grow.
  • Includes a stainless steel mesh plug.
  • Also supports broccoli sprout cultivation.
Cons
  • Its 6.5-inch listed height requires more vertical space than a low-profile lid.

Skip it if you need a low-profile tray for a tight shelf; YOORORO’s 12-hole holder is listed at 2 inches high.

Choose Bylion if you want a combined onion and seed-sprouting setup, including a mesh plug for broccoli sprouts. Its listed 6.5-inch height is worth considering when counter or shelf clearance is limited.

Full product details
BrandBylion
Item Weight1.21 pounds
Item model numberBY00148
ManufacturerBylion
Dimensions3.3 x 3.3 x 6.5 inches

Listed on Amazon as: 2-in-1 Seed Sprouting Set, Green Onion Regrower Kits Onion Planter Scallion

View on Amazon
Marinix Sprouting Kit

#10

10. Marinix Sprouting Kit

  • Dimensions: 5.3 x 8.9 x 7.1 in
  • Weight: 2.8 lb

Best for: Full jar sprouting station.

Why it ranks #10: The broad seed-sprouting set includes two wide-mouth jars and one green onion sprouter, but its primary focus is bean, broccoli and alfalfa sprouts.

Two wide-mouth Mason jars and a dedicated green onion sprouter make Marinix’s kit a broad home-growing station rather than a standalone regrower lid. The included stainless-steel mesh lids, blackout sleeves, drip tray, brush, and stand support several sprouting tasks with accessories supplied together.

The two large wide-mouth jars pair with 304 stainless-steel mesh lids and a stainless-steel stand, giving the kit equipment for jar-based sprouting. Blackout sleeves, a drip tray, and a cleaning brush add practical components for managing light, runoff, and cleanup, while the separate green onion sprouter addresses scallion regrowth. The 5.3-by-8.9-by-7.1-inch listed dimensions can help buyers plan storage or counter placement. Its many pieces suit varied sprouting tasks, but take more setup space than a single lid.

Pros
  • Includes two wide-mouth Mason jars.
  • 304 stainless-steel mesh lids and stand are included.
  • Blackout sleeves, drip tray, and brush support the sprouting workflow.
  • Includes a separate green onion sprouter.
Cons
  • The multi-piece kit has a listed footprint larger than a single planter lid.

Skip it if you only want a compact holder for onion roots; YOORORO’s 12-hole tray measures 4.8 by 2.5 by 2 inches.

This kit suits households interested in both green onion regrowth and other seed sprouts, with jars and supporting accessories included. Allow for its listed 8.9-inch dimension when planning counter placement or storage.

Full product details
BrandMarinix
Item Weight2.8 pounds
Item model numberFYTJ01
ManufacturerMarinix
Dimensions5.3 x 8.9 x 7.1 inches

Listed on Amazon as: Seed Sprouting Kit, 2 Wide Mouth Mason Jars with Sprout Lids, Green Onion Regrower, Stainless Steel Stand, Drain Tray, Blackout Sleeves & Cleaning Brush, Sprouting Jar Kit for Bean, Broccoli, Alfalfa

View on Amazon

Avoiding waterline and jar-fit problems

The most important setup trap is choosing a planter that does not match your jar opening or root size. KCMOSGI Onion Planters explicitly fit wide-mouth Mason jars, while Play as Pro Green Onion Kit is specified for regular-mouth jars; those formats are not interchangeable. Several other listings, including YOORORO Onion Regrower, do not state a jar-mouth size, so verify the opening before purchase rather than assuming compatibility.

The waterline matters too: Play as Pro says its trays suspend roots at the right level to avoid over-soaking and rot. With any water-based setup, keep roots positioned in water while avoiding a fully submerged onion base where possible.

The product data does not establish ideal water-change frequency or guarantee regrowth, so follow the product instructions and check roots regularly for deterioration.

Regrowing roots versus starting from seed

A root-end regrower and a seed-growing kit serve different starting points, so choose based on what you have. Play as Pro Green Onion Kit, SIEGMANNS Onion Regrower, and YOORORO Onion Regrower are described for regrowing existing roots or scallions. Kyoto Kujo Negi Kit instead grows Japanese bunching onions from seeds and gives a specific planting instruction of 68 seeds per jar.

That seed approach is a better fit when you want the named variety, while root-end systems are suited to reusing trimmed onion ends. Do not assume every sprouting kit is primarily an onion planter: Marinix Sprouting Kit is built around seed sprouts and includes one green onion sprouter among its components.

Bylion Sprouting Set also combines onion growing with seed sprouting. Those hybrid products may be useful for multiple tasks, but the dedicated regrowers provide a more direct match for onion-root propagation.

How to Choose a Green Onion Grow Kit

Jar-mouth compatibility

Start by matching the planter to the jar opening you own. KCMOSGI Onion Planters are specified for wide-mouth Mason jars, while Play as Pro Green Onion Kit is explicitly for regular-mouth jars. SIEGMANNS Onion Regrower also specifies standard wide-mouth jars.

In contrast, several listings give product dimensions but no jar-mouth size, so dimensions alone do not confirm fit. If you want to use a jar already in your kitchen, favour products that name its mouth format; if you do not own a jar, check whether one is included, since KCMOSGI states that cups are not included.

Buyers who want a complete setup may prefer a kit that lists jars in its package.

Root capacity and planting method

Choose a root holder that fits the quantity and starting material you plan to grow. YOORORO Onion Regrower provides 12 holes, while each KCMOSGI Onion Planter has seven and the pack contains three planters. Play as Pro Green Onion Kit is described for trimmed root ends, whereas Kyoto Kujo Negi Kit is a seed-based option with guidance to plant 68 seeds per jar.

More holes can help separate several roots, but the product data does not establish how many mature stalks a holder will produce. Buyers reusing multiple kitchen scraps may favour a multi-hole tray; someone seeking Japanese Kujo Negi from seed should choose the dedicated seed kit instead.

What comes in the package

Check whether you are buying a holder alone or a broader growing setup. KCMOSGI Onion Planters supplies three inserts but no cups, and ZESTIGREENS Planter Lid is listed as a lid without a detailed accessory list. Play as Pro Green Onion Kit includes two trays, while Marinix Sprouting Kit lists two wide-mouth jars, mesh lids, sleeves, a drip tray, brush, stand, and one onion sprouter.

The additional parts make Marinix more suited to someone who also wants seed-sprouting gear, although its focus is broader than onion regrowing. If you already own jars and only need a root holder, a simple insert may be enough; for a multi-purpose setup, prioritize clearly listed components.

Which Green Onion Grow Kit Should You Choose?

Choose Play as Pro Green Onion Kit if you want a two-piece root-end setup and own regular-mouth Mason jars; it leads because its intended jar size and suspended-root design are clearly specified. For a wide-mouth jar, SIEGMANNS Onion Regrower is a direct fit, while KCMOSGI Onion Planters offer three seven-hole inserts if you already have the jars. Choose Kyoto Kujo Negi Kit when you want to grow that named Japanese onion from seed rather than regrow scraps.

YOORORO Onion Regrower suits buyers who want a 12-hole tray. If you also want gear for bean or broccoli sprouts, Marinix Sprouting Kit includes jars and accessories, but it is less focused on green onions than the dedicated regrowers.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can green onions regrow indefinitely in water, or do they eventually need soil?

The supplied product details describe regrowing onion scraps in water, but they do not establish that growth continues indefinitely or specify when soil is needed. Treat water regrowing as a way to regrow root ends, not a guarantee of unlimited harvests; choose a seed-based kit if you want to start with seeds.

How often should I change the water in a countertop onion regrower?

The supplied product information does not specify a water-change schedule. Check the instructions for the particular planter you choose, and avoid assuming that all designs handle roots the same way. Play as Pro’s suspended-root design is intended to help avoid over-soaking, but the listing details provided do not give a maintenance interval.

Can a regular-mouth planter fit a wide-mouth Mason jar, or vice versa?

Do not assume the sizes are interchangeable: choose a planter for the jar mouth it names. Play as Pro is designed for regular-mouth Mason jars, while SIEGMANNS is identified as a wide-mouth option. KCMOSGI also offers wide-mouth inserts.

Check your jar’s mouth type before choosing a compatible planter.

Should I choose a seed kit or a scrap-regrowing kit?

Choose based on how you want to start. Kyoto Kujo Negi Kit is the option for growing a named Japanese onion variety from seed. Dedicated regrowers are for using onion scraps or root ends instead.

If you want both functions, the listed 2-in-1 set combines seed sprouting and onion regrowing.

What should I choose if I also want to sprout beans or broccoli?

Marinix’s sprouting kit is the listed option that includes jars and accessories for bean and broccoli sprouts as well as green onion regrowing. If your main goal is growing onions from scraps, a dedicated regrower is more focused; consider Marinix when the additional sprouting uses matter to you.

Final Words

For most shoppers who already own regular-mouth Mason jars, Play as Pro is the clearest choice: its two-piece set is sized for those jars and keeps roots above the water to help avoid over-soaking. Choose SIEGMANNS for wide-mouth compatibility, or KCMOSGI if you want three seven-hole inserts. For growing a Japanese onion from seed, pick Kyoto Kujo Negi; choose Marinix if bean or broccoli sprouting is also a priority.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *